• Upgrade Your Fandom

    Join the Ultimate PHLY Sports Community!

The Anthony Gargano Show | Should Phillies Give JT Realmuto a 3-Year Contract in Free Agency?

PHLY SPORTS Avatar
December 12, 2025
12 12 Phillies thumb 1

Join the PHLY Phillies Podcast as we break down J.T. Realmuto’s free agency and the big question on every Phillies fan’s mind: Should the Phillies offer Realmuto a 3-year contract? We dig into whether a third year makes sense, how the market may shape his value, and what a potential deal could mean for the team moving forward.

AllPHLY.com’s Jim Salisbury joins the show to talk Realmuto’s future, Kyle Schwarber’s return, Ranger Suárez’s next contract, and the latest rumors across MLB free agency.

We finish up the episode with another fun edition of “Remember Me?” trivia that we didn’t get to on Wednesday. The category: Players who signed 5-year deals in free agency over the years.

If you’re a Phillies fan or following MLB offseason news, this is the deep dive you don’t want to miss.

Stay Ahead of the Game: Sign Up for the PHLY Daily

Subscribe now to receive exclusive content, insider insights, and exciting updates right in your inbox.

    Comments

    Share your thoughts

    Join the conversation

    The Comment section is only for diehard members

    Open comments +

    Scroll to next article

    Don't like ads?
    Don't like ads?